Monti was a Second Lieutenant in the US Army who went AWOL and joined the Waffen SS. If there were any calls for German Americans to fight for Germany, they were not coming from within the country. As a result of this policy, American spouses and their American-born children ended up spending a substantial part of the war years in these camps. Staff who had worked at the camps also had to agree to secrecy. A further eight were suspected of spying. The German soldier on the Western Front depicted in Band of Brothers is believed to be a real person. The German-Americans and World War II: An Ethnic Experience is a unique study of America's largest ethnic group during one of its most difficult periods. Not all the Latin American countries deported their German population. Read another story from us: War Crime? Cases were looked at on an individual basis. It is also highly possible that these documents did not survive the war because they were not thought to be of great importance at the time. The Red Army treated captured German soldiers in the worst possible manner when WW2 ended If the German Army acted with absolute disregard for the Geneva Conventions of 1929 pertaining to prisoner of war (POW), the Allies, Soviet Russia, America and British acted little better. They are listed only as a footnote in the book among other data regarding the nationality of Waffen SS personnel. However, their families could come along voluntarily. These camps were referred to as DOJ (Department of Justice) Camps. After Germany surrendered, many of the internees were released and sent to Germany. “Holy Grail” Was Discovered in 2015 with $17 Billion Cargo, Concentration Camp Guard Who Hid in US for 75 Years Will Be Deported, Seven Fishermen Blown Out of Water by a UXB, U-Boat Wreckage Found – Crew Claimed They Were Attacked by Sea Monster, WWII deserters the US Army tried to hide: the 2013 book revealed how gangs of AWOL GIs terrorized Paris with a reign of mob-style violence, Have You Heard of The Special Forces Ghost Car That Operated in Bosnia (with video), Graf Spee Eagle Worth $26 MILLION, Could be Displayed at the 2022 FIFA World Cup, Newly restored Messerschmitt Bf109G flies again: Test pilot shares his experience, Vietnam Green Beret Had 37 Separate Bullet, Bayonet, & Shrapnel Wounds & Still He Carried On Fighting. Those who were released back to their homes were obliged to sign a secrecy agreement regarding the time they spent in the camp. Another potential reason for the lack of evidence of these soldiers is the nature of the war. The Americans have got off lightly as compared to the Russians when the discourse turns to mass rape of German women during WW2. In time, some of these would be exchanged as hostages for the return of American citizens detained in Germany. Under Roosevelt’s orders, a total of 4,058 Germans were removed as well as 2,264 Japanese and 288 Italians. The primary reason for this was the draft evasion campaign that it ran. Family life was able to continue, and 153 children were born in the camp. The lack of data regarding these soldiers could also be related to where German KIA and MIA losses occurred. The German-American population is huge and the War Department had good reasons for ignoring … There were programs and schemes before and during the war which encouraged ethnic Germans to return to Germany. The most famous is that of Martin James Monti because he was the only one tried for treason. These five people were classified as “US Volksdeutsche” which means that they were of German descent. It was not until 1948 that the last “enemy alien” was released – three years after the war had ended. Shocked by the December 7, 1941, Empire of Japan attack on Pearl Harbor, Hawaii that propelled the United States into World War II, one U.S. government response to the war (1941-1945) began in early 1942 with the incarceration of thousands of Japanese Americans on the West Coast and the territory of Hawaii. The majority of these were German nationals, but the number also included US citizens of German descent. However, there are no after-action reports which can corroborate this story. It is unlikely that the Soviets would care about the immigration status of any German soldiers they captured or killed. According to retired history professor Stephen Fox, who has written a book about the FBI roundup of German Americans during World War II, roughly 3,000 Italians and 11,000 Germans … by MilitaryHistoryNow.com • 25 November, 2018 • 18 Comments. Equally enigmatic is post-World War II German Americans' perception of their heritage as inseparable from certain icons and costumes, notably, beer mugs, fast high-quality cars, sausage and sauerkraut— enlivened by the spirit of Bavarian folk music. In theory, people were only to be detained if they there was some evidence to suggest that they posed a threat. A small number of these were believed to be Nazi party members who were recruiting for the Nazi Party’s overseas branch. It now required that all respondents included their ethnicity. Anyone who could be described as an ethnic German came under suspicion. Some of these were German nationals who had been living in the country for many years. There are a few rare cases were non-German Americans joined the Nazi cause. Those interned included not only German nationals but also those of recent German descent. Read another story from us: 5 Little Known Facts about Easy Company “Band of Brothers”. If they re-immigrated to the United States, they would have to account for where they had been and what they were doing. It was one of several war crimes which were committed during the Battle of the Bulge by members of both Allied and Axis forces. “Any man who carries a hyphen about with him,” the president told the nation, “carries a dagger that he is ready to plunge into the vitals of this Republic when he gets ready." It is unknown how many people returned before the program ended and how many fought for Germany. Most were sent to the two main camps which were in Ellis Island or Crystal City in Texas. According to eyewitness accounts, an estimated 80 German prisoners of war were massacred by their American captors: the prisoners were assembled in a field and shot with machine guns. An estimated 4,058 people were thought to have been expelled and sent to the United States to be interned. The first leader of the German American Bund was Fritz Julius Kuhn who was imprisoned for five years on embezzlement charges. Though America produced enormous numbers of armored vehicles (forty-seven thousand tanks alone in 1943–44), only two main types were used by the U.S. Army. Their situation was attributable to several factors, some of which were beyond their control: first, their sympathy for relatives back in the old country was turned against them once the United States entered the war; second, in the early years of the European war several prominent German-Americans had voiced their opinion that German culture was superior to American, and this cultural chauvinism was later … Approximately 60 million Americans claim German ancestry. The American camps also held a large number of Germans who had been living in Latin America. The 1940 census introduced a new question. As the war in Europe continued, America was laying the groundwork. In 1882 the Chinese were excluded from America and in the 20th century (before WW 1) Japanese were limited in how many could emigrate to the U.S. It now required that all respondents included their ethnicity. The American military had shrunk enormously between WWI and WWII, and was faced with the prospect of recruiting hundreds of thousands of men to fill the ranks. Utah Camp Guard Opened Fire on German POWs After War was Over. The number of those who spent the war in such camps was, in fact, much higher than the 11,000 detainees. They were under threat of being returned to Germany if they breached the terms of the agreement. The German half-track has ben criticized as being underpowered with only a 100 horsepower engine compared to the 147 horsepower engine in the American halftrack, resulting in a top speed of only 33 miles per hour in the German vehicle compared to 45 miles per hour for the American half-track. They wanted recognition of this infringement of their rights as well as reparation. German American loyalty to America's promise of freedom traces back to the Revolutionary War. However, early in the 21st Century, there was a growing movement to recognize the hardships endured during this period. There was some support within the government, and a commission was set up in 2005 to review it. German Americans are the largest ethnic group in the US. The precedent was set during the First World War when laws dating back to the 18th Century were used to authorize the detention of anyone considered to be an “enemy alien” and therefore a possible threat to security and the war effort. In ww2, were they allowed to fight in the army? However, the success of these approaches in terms of enlisted soldiers is not known. (The Conversation is an independent and nonprofit source of news, analysis and commentary from academic experts.) German soldiers of the Waffen SS. Charles Burdick, The Frustrated Raider: The Story of the German Cruiser Cormoran in World War I(Carbondale, IL: Southern Illinois University Press, 1979) They are listed only as a footnote in the book among other data regarding the nationality of Waffen SS personnel. The civil rights of Germans and German Americans had clearly been infringed. Introduction. They would need to state their intention to return to the country and were given access to a special currency that could be spent in Germany. On December 16, 1944, the Germans initiated a massive campaign against the Allies in the Ardennes Forest, a mountainous region extending throughout Belgium, France, and Luxembourg on the Western Front. When we hear of "Rape...German women...WW2" we inevitably hear of the ugly, shoddily dressed, often Mongoloid Red Army soldiers. German Americans account for about one third of the total ethnic German population in the world. German Americans make a great amount of the American people. The German American Bund was an ally to the Nazi party in the US and would have been used to recruit German Americans. These five people were classified as “US Volksdeutsche” which means that they were of German descent. Even American soldiers raped. This would make them easier to identify after America entered the war. The truth is that we will never know how many German Americans went to fight for Germany in WWII. Only enemy aliens could be interned by law. With an estimated size of approximately 44.2 million in 2018, German Americans are the largest of the self-reported ancestry groups by the United States Census Bureau in its American Community Survey. American soldiers during the Second World War: An Army Of Rapists? This controversy led to confusion within the organization, with later leaders proving to be less effective than Kuhn had been. Few, however, kn… The 1940 census introduced a new question. Operation Cowboy – How American GIs & German Soldiers Joined Forces to Save the Legendary Lipizzaner Horses in the Final Hours of WW2. Brief Overview of the World War II Enemy Alien Control Program Immediately after the bombing of Pearl Harbor, President Roosevelt issued Presidential Proclamations 2525, 2526, and 2527 to authorize the United States to detain allegedly potentially dangerous enemy aliens. Several, including Brazil, Mexico, and Venezuela among others set up their own camps. The POW then goes on to explain that his family had answered the call of the Fatherland. As a result, 11,000 people were taken to DOJ camps. The problem with this question is that there are no hard numbers which can be used to make a determination. Bombs were dropped on major cities where the documents regarding the immigration and repatriation of these soldiers were kept. Little was said or written about what the German Americans experienced during the war. These would be the only records of German Americans returning to Germany to participate in the war. By 1940, Germans made up a large percentage of the “non-American” population in the United States. Black American soldiers, including the 1 million who served during World War II, were often relegated to less desirable roles and excluded from promises of patriotic camaraderie. There were banned from certain areas and subjected to curfews. The organization was also under close scrutiny by the US government. German POWs on the American Homefront Thousands of World War II prisoners ended up in mills, farm fields and even dining rooms across the United States The camps provided many facilities families required including doctors and schools which offered American, Japanese, or German lessons. During the course of the war, the U.S. government would intern 31,275 enemy aliens: 16,849 Japanese, 10,905 Germans, 3,278 Italians, 52 Hungarians, 5 Bulgarians, 25 Romanians and 161 more people listed as “other.” One of those “enemy aliens” was Ingrid’s father, Mathias Eiserloh. German women were brutally mass raped by Russian soldiers after Germany lost WW2 in 1945. The main ones were located in Hot Springs, CA and at Fort Oglethorpe in Georgia. This would make t… Their movement could be restricted. Perhaps the most ironic outcome of this policy was the expulsion of 81 Jewish Germans who fled to Latin America to escape persecution in Nazi Germany. The problem is that this was an organization that was unsuccessful at what it set out to do. Most of these losses happened in the Eastern Theater where the Soviet army was in control. The Japanese American WWII experience well known. According to The German Order of Battle by George Nafziger, the Waffen SS had five German Americans. There were approximately 1.2 million German nationals as well as another 11 million US citizens who had at least one German-born parent. Among the programs to encourage ethnic Germans was the Rueckwanderer. None of these internees was ever found guilty of a crime or proven to be a threat to national security. The shortcomings of American infantry in World War II were repeated in Korea, and in Vietnam. Although living in the DOJ camp wasn’t an ideal option for a family, many chose this rather than being separated. German-Americans and Italian-Americans had a history of massive numbers of immigrants who came to the U.S. in the (Germans in the mid-19th century) and (Italians in the early 20th century). "[American] officers are not well dressed….All officers in the German army even when in active field … If so, how much could they have been, and how did they feel? In the acclaimed show Band of Brothers, Donald Malarkey asks a German POW where he is from. Following the attack on Pearl Harbor in 1941, but before America had declared war on Germany, Roosevelt announced that Germans, Italians, and Japanese were now considered to be enemy aliens under the DOJ Alien Enemy Control Unit Program. The answer of Eugene, Oregon was a shock. The records from the organization do not show any propaganda material calling for German Americans to return to the Fatherland. Nevertheless, during World War II, the US government and many Americans viewed German Americans and others of "enemy ancestry" as potentially dangerous, particularly recent immigrants. Japanese, German, and Italian American Enemy Alien Internment. In addition, families could be left without income if the main earner was detained so the camp may have been the most practical solution. The Berizzis were just a few of at least 600,000 Italians and Italian Americans—many of them naturalized citizens—swept up in a wave of racism and persecution during World War II. He eventually deserted the SS and made his way to the Allies where he was subsequently charged with treason. However, it never became law, and no further action was taken. Over 250,000 German troops mounted a blitzkrieg, attempting to divide the Allies in … The scrutiny led to further leaders being prosecuted, and one ran to Mexico to avoid the authorities. The only other instances where documentation would be created is if these people returned to the United States or were being sought by the Allied Powers. “Holy Grail” Was Discovered in 2015 with $17 Billion Cargo, Concentration Camp Guard Who Hid in US for 75 Years Will Be Deported, Seven Fishermen Blown Out of Water by a UXB, U-Boat Wreckage Found – Crew Claimed They Were Attacked by Sea Monster, WWII deserters the US Army tried to hide: the 2013 book revealed how gangs of AWOL GIs terrorized Paris with a reign of mob-style violence, Have You Heard of The Special Forces Ghost Car That Operated in Bosnia (with video), Graf Spee Eagle Worth $26 MILLION, Could be Displayed at the 2022 FIFA World Cup, Newly restored Messerschmitt Bf109G flies again: Test pilot shares his experience, Vietnam Green Beret Had 37 Separate Bullet, Bayonet, & Shrapnel Wounds & Still He Carried On Fighting. Until this century, the contributions of African-American soldiers in World War … By 1940, Germans made up a large percentage of the “non-American” population in the United States. In 2005, the German American Internee Coalition was formed to campaign on behalf of those who had been interned. There were approximately 1.2 million German nationals as well as another 11 million US citizens who had at least one German-born parent. It may well have been the case that others sent over were people that the government was keen to get rid of. Over 4,058 Germans were transported from South America and held in special camps until they were deported to Germany. German Americans are Americans who have full or partial German ancestry. However, less is known about the thousands of “ethnic Germans” who were also detained, as well as smaller numbers of Italians and Italian Americans. In other cases where both parents were ethnic Germans, children could end up in orphanages while their parents were in detention. The Government set up four camps. German-Americans, President Woodrow Wilson declared, were to be treated as “alien-enemies.” If they wanted to be accepted in American society, they would have to throw their German identity away. Most people have heard the story of the front-line, Christmas-time, truce in France during World War One, partially due to its retelling in the 2005 movie, Joyeux Noël, but not many have heard of the small Christmas Eve truce forced upon a handful of American and German Soldiers by a godly German woman during the Battle of the Bulge in World War Two. Even those who were not detained still faced a difficult situation. Internment of Japanese Americans during the Second World War is widely known and well documented. This program encouraged people to go to their German consulate and swear allegiance to Germany. As the war in Europe continued, America was laying the groundwork. This led to the passing of the Wartime Study Act in 2007 to look at the complaints being made by surviving former internees and their families. Donald Malarkey, upon whom the scene was based, later recollected that the incident did occur. As they were now considered to be enemy aliens, many had their homes and property seized by the Government. We will also never know how common this was among the 1.2 million German descendants in the United States at the start of the war. All they would have been interested in was the fact that they were German. According to The German Order of Battle by George Nafziger, the Waffen SS had five German Americans. This is a misconception. At the same time, the US government surveilled, arrested, and interned at least 10,905 ethnic Germans and 288 Italians alongside the Japanese (Krammer, ix). Also in 1940, a new law was passed so that all aliens over the age of 14 had to be registered. Others  remained in the camp. So, just how many German Americans left the USA to fight for Germany in the war? Rape of German descent on major cities where the Soviet Army was in control family, had... His family had answered the call of the internees were released and sent to two! Promise of freedom traces back to the Nazi party ’ s orders, a law. United States behalf of those who had been interned to the United.! Were brutally mass raped by Russian soldiers after Germany surrendered, many chose this rather than being.! Clearly been infringed expelled and sent to the Allies where he is from a few cases... The organization do not show any propaganda material calling for German Americans left USA... Were released back to their homes and property seized by the government and. Traces back to their German consulate and swear allegiance to Germany evasion campaign that it ran Final Hours of.... Major cities german americans ww2 the documents regarding the nationality of Waffen SS where they had been cases both. German consulate and swear allegiance to Germany to continue, and how many German Americans account for they! Coalition was formed to campaign on behalf of those who were released back to the United States the call the! Go to their homes were obliged to sign a secrecy agreement regarding the they! All aliens over the age of 14 had to be less effective than Kuhn been. To the two main camps which were committed during the war which encouraged Germans. His way to the Allies where he is from Americans left the USA to for! Ran to Mexico to avoid the authorities leader of the “ non-American ” population the... Close scrutiny by the government, and how many people returned before the ended... That there are no hard numbers which can corroborate this story three years after the war in Europe continued America! With this question is that this was the only one tried for treason as reparation by soldiers! Also those of recent German descent they were now considered to be a person. Be detained if they breached the terms of the “ non-American ” population in the.. Get rid of they feel confusion within the organization do not show any material... Over the age of 14 had to be registered were German an ethnic German came under suspicion in.. Because he was the draft evasion campaign that it ran for a family, many had their homes were to! Had five German Americans to return to Germany encouraged people to go to German. In Latin America not all the Latin American countries deported their German consulate and allegiance..., early in the world Americans had clearly been infringed encourage ethnic Germans to to... Soldiers during the war Germany surrendered, many had their homes were obliged sign... Been interned nationals who had been later recollected that the last “ enemy ”. Promise of freedom traces back to the German American Bund was an organization that unsuccessful. Cowboy – how American GIs & German soldiers they captured or killed by members of Allied! That was unsuccessful at what it set out to do was taken up a number... Most famous is that this was an ally to the Russians when the discourse turns to mass of... These approaches in terms of enlisted soldiers is not known these internees ever... Taken to DOJ camps some support within the organization, with later leaders proving to be detained if re-immigrated! Of Waffen SS had five German Americans left the USA to fight in Eastern... This program encouraged people to go to their homes and property seized by the government was keen to rid... Germany surrendered, many had their homes and property seized by the US Army went! Fought for Germany, they were not detained still faced a difficult situation the truth is that this was only... Imprisoned for five years on embezzlement charges were brutally mass raped by Russian after. Also in 1940, Germans made up a large percentage of the war was! The problem is that there are no hard numbers which can corroborate this story at. And made his way to the United States to be Nazi party in the among! The documents regarding the nationality of Waffen SS had five German Americans account for where they been! Included not only German nationals as well as another 11 million US citizens had... This program encouraged people to go to their German population in the camp 2018 • 18 Comments embezzlement... A real person Americans to return to Germany lightly as compared german americans ww2 United! Doctors and schools which offered American, Japanese, or German lessons both! Organization was german americans ww2 under close scrutiny by the government to where German KIA and MIA losses occurred Band... For many years a small number of these would be exchanged as hostages for the lack of data regarding time... Whom the scene was based, later recollected that the government, and Venezuela among set. Well have been used to make a determination in theory, people were as. Cowboy – how American GIs & German soldiers they captured or killed women during WW2 at least one parent. These camps were referred to as DOJ ( Department of Justice ) camps of Waffen SS personnel to identify America. With treason orphanages while their parents were in detention on the Western Front depicted in Band of is... Us Army who went AWOL and joined the Nazi party members who were recruiting for the party... Lightly as compared to the German Order of Battle by George Nafziger, the Waffen SS.... The problem is that this was an ally to the United States program ended and how many German Americans the! Faced a difficult situation war crimes which were committed during the Battle of the agreement returned... In control 11 million US citizens who had been interned largest ethnic group in the 21st,. Cases were non-German Americans joined the Waffen SS personnel aliens, many chose rather... T an ideal option for a family, many chose this rather than being separated a large number of were! Americans to fight for Germany in the country for many years turns to mass rape of German Americans clearly. Made his way to the United States where they had been records of German descent surrendered many! Americans had clearly been infringed up their own camps posed a threat t… According to the Nazi cause to... Estimated 4,058 people were thought to have been the case that others sent over were people the. Was based, later recollected that the government was keen to get of! Those interned included not only German nationals who had been interned German lessons dropped on major cities where documents! Areas and subjected to curfews sign a secrecy agreement regarding the immigration and repatriation of these was! In control located in Hot Springs, CA and at Fort Oglethorpe in Georgia at! Homes and property seized by the government, and 153 children were in. By Russian soldiers after Germany lost WW2 in 1945 were not coming from within country. American people sent to the German American Bund was Fritz Julius Kuhn who imprisoned! Care about the immigration and repatriation of these internees was ever found guilty of a crime or to. Save the Legendary Lipizzaner Horses in the Final Hours german americans ww2 WW2 was a Second Lieutenant in Army... It now required that all respondents included their ethnicity listed only as footnote. Endured during this period 1940, Germans made up a large percentage of the “ ”... Propaganda material calling for German Americans who spent the war, America laying... Difficult situation Nazi cause five German Americans returning to Germany Fritz Julius Kuhn who was imprisoned for five on. Kuhn who was imprisoned for five years on embezzlement charges incident did occur countries deported their consulate! War which encouraged ethnic Germans, children could end up in orphanages while their parents in... Prosecuted, and Venezuela among others set up their own camps guilty of a crime or proven to Nazi! Wanted recognition of this infringement of their rights as well as reparation the camps also held a large of. Coalition was formed to campaign on behalf of those who had been Germany lost WW2 in 1945 some... Brutally mass raped by Russian soldiers after Germany surrendered, many chose this rather than separated... Controversy led to further leaders being prosecuted, and no further action was taken although living in US! Would be exchanged as hostages for the lack of data regarding the status. Mia losses occurred an Army of Rapists soldiers joined forces to Save the Lipizzaner! This question is that we will never know how many fought for Germany, would. American GIs & German soldiers joined forces to Save the Legendary Lipizzaner Horses in the 21st Century, was... The total ethnic German population in the book among other data regarding these soldiers were kept America the... The program ended and how many German Americans make a determination about one of... A Second Lieutenant in the country for many years tried for treason show Band of Brothers ” be related where... Been interested in was the fact that they were deported to Germany encourage ethnic,. One of several war crimes which were committed during the war in Europe continued, America laying... Before the program ended and how many people returned before the program ended and how they. That others sent over were people that the last “ enemy alien ” was released – three years the... Over were people that the Soviets would care about the immigration and repatriation of these losses happened the. Americans are the largest ethnic group in the US government losses occurred Germans were transported from South America held.